
We compare standard hydraulic, servo-hydraulic, hybrid and all-electric injection molding machines in a balanced way in terms of energy, precision, cleanliness, tonnage and investment, with examples from the Haitian MARS, JUPITER and Zhafir series.
When buying a plastic injection molding machine, one of the most frequently asked questions is about drive technology: servo-hydraulic or all-electric? Each technology has areas where it is strong, and the "best" option depends on the part you will produce, the tonnage and your operating priorities. In this article we outline a general framework and give examples from Haitian's relevant series.
What are the technologies, in brief?
- Conventional hydraulic: The pump runs continuously and movements are driven by oil pressure. Energy is consumed even while the machine is idle.
- Servo-hydraulic: The hydraulic pump is driven by a servo motor; the motor runs only at the speed required. The power and flexibility of the hydraulic system are retained, while energy consumption is noticeably reduced.
- All-electric: Clamping, injection and plasticizing movements are performed by servo motors and mechanical transmission elements; the hydraulic oil circuit is practically negligible.
- Hybrid and electric with integrated hydraulics: Some axes are electric and others are hydraulic; the aim is to combine the advantages of the two approaches.
General comparison
| Feature | Servo-hydraulic | All-electric |
|---|---|---|
| Energy consumption | Noticeably lower than conventional hydraulic. | Generally at the lowest level. |
| Precision and repeatability | Good with modern controls and sensors. | Very high, since movements are controlled directly by servo motors. |
| Cycle speed | Varies by configuration; fast options are available. | Can be advantageous for fast-cycle jobs at small and medium scale. |
| Cleanliness | Has a hydraulic oil circuit; leak and maintenance management is required. | Oil volume is very small; suitable for clean production. |
| Tonnage range | Offers a wide range from small to very large tonnages. | Generally common in small and medium tonnages. |
| Investment cost | Generally lower. | Generally higher. |
| Maintenance | Requires maintenance of oil, filters, seals and hoses. | Little oil maintenance; the servo drive and mechanical transmission parts are monitored. |
The table shows general trends. Exact values vary by brand, model and configuration; the technical documentation of the relevant model should be reviewed before making a decision.
Examples from the Haitian portfolio
- Servo-hydraulic: MARS 5 (according to Haitian, its best-selling series with more than 410,000 units sold), MARS III/SE, MARS GII+, MARS 5/h, and the two-platen JUPITER 5 and JUPITER V/SE. For MARS 5 and JUPITER 5, with electric plasticizing (pre-molding) equipment, Haitian points to a 20-40% higher energy saving rate. It also states that its patented servo-hydraulic drive systems can reduce energy costs by up to 60%; actual savings vary depending on the machine and the application.
- Electric (Zhafir): Zeres 5 (electric with integrated hydraulics), Venus 5 (all-electric), Jenius 5 (hybrid electric, two-platen) and ZEV-F for fast-cycle applications (150 to 650 tons of clamping force).
Which one stands out in which situation?
Servo-hydraulic generally stands out in the following situations:
- If large and heavy parts, high tonnages and a large mold area are required
- In general-purpose production with a variety of molds and parts
- If the investment budget is a decisive criterion
- If hydraulic maintenance infrastructure and experience are already in place
All-electric generally stands out in the following situations:
- In fields that require clean and precise production, such as medical, optics and electronics
- If very high repeatability and tight tolerances are required
- In long-running, fast series production at small and medium tonnages
- If energy cost weighs heavily in the investment decision
- If the risk of oil leaks in the production environment is not wanted
How should energy savings be interpreted?
The savings rates announced by manufacturers are based on specific test conditions; the result in your own production varies according to part weight, cycle time, the machine's utilization rate and idle times. For a realistic assessment, calculate together the machine's annual operating hours, its average power draw and your electricity unit price; if possible, ask the seller for measured values from a similar application. Energy savings are only one item: maintenance, spare parts and ease of operation also affect the total cost of ownership.
Common misunderstandings
- "All-electric is better for every job." It depends on the application, the tonnage and the budget; for large and heavy parts, servo-hydraulic and two-platen solutions stand out.
- "Servo-hydraulic is old technology." With servo motor technology, the power and flexibility of hydraulics are combined, and in many applications energy consumption is noticeably reduced.
- "The difference between the technologies is only about energy." Cleanliness, precision, maintenance and investment cost are also decision criteria.
Ask yourself when deciding
- What are the weight, wall thickness and tolerance of the part?
- Which tonnage class do the mold dimensions and the required clamping force point to?
- Does production require a cleanroom or a similar hygiene condition?
- What are your target cycle time and annual operating hours? Energy savings are assessed by multiplying by operating hours.
- Which technology are your maintenance team and spare parts supply better prepared for?
The answers to these questions often give a clear direction of preference between the two technologies. For a final selection, model-specific technical values need to be consulted.
Let's evaluate it together
If you would like to evaluate together which drive technology will suit your production, contact us with your part and mold information. For the full set of selection criteria, you can take a look at our 8-criteria guide and our products page.
